Your Guess is as Good as Mine

Meaning
The proverb “Your guess is as good as mine” is used when someone admits they don’t know the answer to a question and that any suggestion or assumption is equally uncertain. It shows humility, honesty, and acceptance of uncertainty. Rather than pretending to know, the speaker acknowledges that they are in the same position as the other person—both are unsure, and both are equally qualified (or unqualified) to make a guess.

Understanding the Idea of the Proverb
It highlights the limits of knowledge, honesty in communication, and the shared experience of uncertainty.

A Beautiful and Relatable Moral Story
Two friends, Ankit and Rohan, were watching the night sky. Suddenly, a bright streak of light shot across the darkness. Ankit gasped, “Was that a shooting star or a comet?”

Rohan, trying to sound knowledgeable, said, “Of course, it’s a comet. They always look like that.” But a moment later, he scratched his head, realizing he wasn’t entirely sure.

Ankit laughed and asked again, “So, really, what do you think it was?”

This time Rohan smiled sheepishly and said, “Honestly, your guess is as good as mine. I don’t know either.”

Instead of ending the conversation, this admission opened a new door. They pulled out their phones and began searching for answers. They read about meteors, comets, and satellites. They learned that shooting stars are actually meteors burning in the Earth’s atmosphere. By the end of the evening, not only had they discovered the truth, but they had also enjoyed the process of learning together.

Later that week, in school, when the science teacher asked, “What causes a shooting star?” Rohan proudly raised his hand and explained it perfectly. Ankit winked at him, remembering the night sky conversation.

Rohan realized something important: pretending to know everything can close the door to real learning. But admitting ignorance—saying “your guess is as good as mine”—invites curiosity, collaboration, and growth.

---

Moral
Honesty about what you don’t know creates space for learning and discovery. It is better to admit uncertainty than to fake knowledge.

---